Table 2: Characteristics of inventions, cardiovascular risks and/or events of included studies.
Study Authors |
Intervention |
Comparators/Control |
Cardiovascular Risks Benefits |
Adverse Effects |
Mortality |
Al-Qudimat, et al., 2021 |
IM TU every 12 weeks |
Untreated |
Reduction in TG, WC, BMI, FLI
|
|
T-25 (7.8%) C- 28 (15.2%) |
Alwani, et al., 2021 |
IM TU 1000 mg every 12 weeks |
Untreated |
Improvement in wt, WC, BMI, ED, BP, PR, HbA1c, TG, T-Chol, HDL
|
No MACE recorded |
NR |
Anderson, et al., 2016 |
Different T formulation (gel, injection & oral pills) |
Untreated |
Normal TRT to those with persistently low T HR: 0.74, CI 0.56-0.98, P = 0.04
|
Higher MACE & death with age < 65 years with low T |
3-year rates of death (4.3%) and MACE (6.6%) |
Aversa, et al., 2010 |
IM TU 1000 mg every 12 weeks |
PLB |
Improvement in WC, CIMT, hs-CRP, HOMA-IR |
T- mild erythrocytosis (3) PLB – MI (1)
|
NR |
Aversa, et al., 2012 |
IM TU 1000 mg every 12 weeks
|
Untreated |
Reduction in hs-CRP, WC |
NR |
NR |
Basaria, et al., 2015 |
7.5g of T gel with variation in dosing |
PLB |
No difference in CIMT & Carotid calcium scores |
No difference in MACE T- Stroke (2), MI (1)
|
T- 2 PLB - 3 |
Francomano, et al 2014a |
IM TU 1000 mg every 12 weeks |
Untreated |
Improvement in wt, WC, BP, HbA1c, HOMA-IR, T-Chol, HDL |
Increased haematocrit, PSA although within acceptable limits
|
NR |
Francomano, et al., 2014b |
IM TU 1000 mg every 12 weeks |
Untreated |
Improvement in EF, DF, CIMT, Fibrinogen, microalbuminuria, T-Chol, endo fn.
|
No MACE recorded |
NR |
Groti, et al., 2018 |
IM TU 1000 mg every 10 weeks |
PLB |
Improvement in FMD, CIMT, WC, BMI, HbA1C, HOMA-IR, T-Chol
|
No MACE recorded |
NR |
Groti, et al., 2020a |
IM TU 1000 mg every 10 weeks
|
PLB for the first year only |
NR |
No adverse CV events or PAEs |
NR |
Groti, et al., 2020b |
IM TU 1000 mg every 10 weeks |
PLB for the first year only |
Reduction in the FPG, HbA1c, HOMA-IR, CIMT improved FMD, lipid profile
|
No adverse events or side effects observed |
NR |
Hackett, et al., 2013 |
IM TU 1000 mg at 0, 6, 18 weeks then dosage during open label unspecified |
PLB for the first 30 weeks, then 106 (from both T & PLB received medication unspecified |
Improved ED |
No significant Adverse effects, Injection related pain
No assessment for MACE
|
Death unrelated to TRT |
Hackett, et al., 2014 |
IM TU 1000 mg at 0, 6, 18 weeks then dosage during open label unspecified |
PLB for the first 30 weeks, then 106 (from both T & PLB received medication unspecified
|
Reduction in Wt, WC, BMI and improvement in HOMA-IR |
Mild Adverse effects- injection site pain No MACE recorded |
NR |
Hackett, et al., 2018 |
IM TU given and some changed to T gel |
PLB /Untreated |
Reduced mortality with those with Normal T & TRT treated with age > 64.5 years and Wt < 93.8 kg |
|
Mortality T treated -6.2%, 0% on continuous treatment, Untreated – 16.9%
|
Hackett, et al., 2020 |
IM TU 1000 mg at 0, 6, 18 weeks then dosage during open label unspecified |
PLB/Untreated |
Continuous reduction in visceral fat & decrease in WC seen in the follow up phase |
No difference in non-fatal MACE between U- (19.8/1,000 years) and treated with T (15.2/1,000 years)
|
NR |
Haider, et al., 2014 |
IM TU 1000 mg every 12 weeks |
Untreated |
Improvement in WC, Wt, BMI, BP, HbA1c, lipid profile
|
No Mace recorded |
NR |
Haider, et al., 2016 |
IM TU 1000 mg every 12 weeks |
Untreated |
Decrease in Wt, BMI, WC, HrtR, PR, BP, HbA1c, lipid pattern
|
No MACE recorded |
NR |
Heufelder, et al., 2009 |
Transdermal 50 mg T gel daily |
Untreated |
Improvement in HbA1c, FPG, HDL, TG, WC
|
NR |
NR |
Jones, et al., 2011 |
Transdermal (60 mg) 2% T gel daily |
PLB daily |
Reduction in HOMA-IR, HbA1C, Lpa, LDL, T-chol |
Erythema, pruritus and nasopharyngitis CV events T- 4.6% PLB- 10.7%
|
NR |
Maggi, et al., 2016 |
Different T formulations (gel, patch & injection) |
Untreated |
NR |
MACE similar in T &U. MI (14), DVT (13), stroke (9)
|
T-3 U-2 |
Sharma, et al., 2015 |
Different T formulations dosing (injection, gel & patch) |
Untreated |
Decreased all-cause death, stroke and MI in normalized T group
|
High CVD cohort recruited |
NR |
Shores, et al., 2012 |
Different T formulations & dosing (IM cypionate & enanthate- 2 weekly; gel and patches)
|
Untreated |
NR |
NR |
T- 41 (10.3%) U- 131 (20.7%) |
Vigen, et al., 2013 |
Different T formulations (gel, patch & injection) |
Untreated |
NR |
MACE: T-25.7% ; U- 19.9% |
T- 67(5.47%) U- 681 (9.09%) |
BMI: Body Mass Index; CIMT: Carotid Initima-media thickness; CV: Cardiovascular; DF: Diastolic Function; ED: Erectile Dysfunction; EF: Ejection Fraction; Endo fn: Endothelial function; FLI: Fatty Liver Index; FMD: Flow-Mediated Dilatation; HR: Hazard Ratio; HrtR: Heart Rate; hs-CRP: High-sensitive C-reactive protein; LDL: Low Density Lipoprotein; Lpa: Lipoprotein little a; MACE: Major Adverse Cardiovascular Events; NR: Not Recorded; PAEs: Prostatic Adverse Events; PR: Pulse Rate; T: Testosterone; T-Chol: Total Cholesterol; TG: Triglycerides; TRT: Testosterone Replacement Therapy; U: Untreated; WC: Waist Circumference; Wt: Weight