Table 1: Characteristics and key findings of representative included studies.
|
Study (Year) |
Design |
Technology Domain |
Key Findings |
Educational Level |
Country/Region |
Ref. |
|
Gordon, et al. (2024) |
Scoping review |
AI/ML in medical education |
278 studies; surge after 2018; AI used in assessment, surgical training, and diagnostic reasoning |
UME/GME/CPD |
Multi-country |
[1] |
|
Lucas, et al. (2024) |
Systematic review |
LLMs in medical education |
40 studies; 42.5% evaluated LLMs in examinations; potential for personalized learning |
UME/GME |
USA |
[12] |
|
Liu, et al. (2024) |
SR + meta-analysis |
ChatGPT/LLMs |
GPT-4 passed licensing examinations; accuracy 60-90% across countries; outperformed GPT-3.5 |
UME |
Multi-country |
[20] |
|
Tene, et al. (2024) |
Umbrella review |
VR/AR in medical education |
30 reviews; VR/AR improved performance and engagement; most primary studies methodologically weak |
UME/GME |
Multi-country |
[14] |
|
Elendu, et al. (2024) |
Narrative review |
Simulation-based training |
SBT enhanced skills and reduced errors; VR, gamification, and telemedicine simulations effective |
UME/GME |
Nigeria |
[5] |
|
Ogundiya, et al. (2024) |
Narrative review |
Digital medical education |
25 years of digital education; LMS, telemedicine, AI, and metaverse transforming education |
UME/GME/CPD |
UK |
[2] |
|
Mergen & Graf (2024) |
Scoping review |
VR in medical education |
69 reviews; VR used for surgical training and anatomy; limited fully immersive studies |
UME/GME |
Germany |
[24] |
|
McGee, et al. (2024) |
Systematic review |
Digital clinical skills |
Digital tools effective for clinical-skill teaching; benefits include flexibility and accessibility |
UME |
Australia |
[6] |
|
Laupichler, et al. (2024) |
Quasi-experimental |
LLM-generated MCQs |
ChatGPT items comparable to human-generated; students could not distinguish origin |
UME |
Germany |
[19] |
|
Martinengo,et al. (2024) |
SR + meta-analysis |
Spaced digital education |
Spaced digital education improved knowledge and skill retention versus massed delivery |
UME/GME/CPD |
Singapore |
[18] |
|
Marsilio, et al. (2024) |
Cross-sectional |
Digital readiness/telehealth |
83% desired telemedicine training; 76% wished to incorporate telehealth into future practice |
UME/GME |
Italy |
[16] |
|
García-Robles, et al. (2024) |
SR + meta-analysis |
iVR/AR in anatomy |
XR technologies improved anatomy knowledge; positive student perceptions of usefulness |
UME |
Spain |
[15] |
|
Sun, et al. (2023) |
Systematic review |
AI in healthcare/med ed |
AI mainly applied in radiology and surgical training; students positive toward AI curricula |
UME/GME |
China |
[9] |
|
Abd-Alrazaq, et al. (2023) |
Perspective/review |
LLMs in medical education |
LLMs offer personalized learning and clinical-reasoning support; accuracy and bias are concerns |
UME/GME |
Qatar |
[22] |
|
Nagi, et al. (2023) |
Scoping review |
AI in medical education |
AI applications focused on assessment, feedback, and adaptive learning; limited empirical data |
UME |
UAE |
[25] |
Note: UME = Undergraduate Medical Education; GME = Graduate Medical Education; CPD = Continuing Professional Development; SR = Systematic Review; LLMs = Large Language Models; VR = Virtual Reality; AR = Augmented Reality; iVR = Immersive Virtual Reality; SBT = Simulation-Based Training; MCQs = Multiple-Choice Questions