Table 1: Key characteristics of the studies included in this meta-analysis.
Study name |
r |
n |
Gratitude measure |
Depression measure |
Cross1/Long2 |
% Female |
Mean age |
Country of research |
Sample description |
Alkozei, et al. [31] |
-0.57 |
88 |
GRAT |
BDI-II |
Cross |
47 |
19 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Allenden, et al. [32] |
-0.37 |
278 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
64 |
653 |
Australia |
Retirees |
Begg [33] thesis |
-0.47 |
649 |
GQ-6 |
DASS-214 |
Cross |
79 |
31 |
Australia |
Adults |
Bryan, et al. [42] |
-0.46 |
352 |
GQ-6 |
BSI |
Cross |
84 |
24 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Celano, et al. [43] |
-0.50 |
164 |
GQ-6 |
PHQ-9 |
Cross |
16 |
61 |
USA |
Cardiac patients |
Chamizo-Nieto, et al. [44] |
-0.28 |
835 |
GQ-65 |
DASS-214 |
Cross |
54 |
16 |
Spain |
Adolescents |
Corona, et al. [45] study 2 a |
-0.54 |
121 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
84 |
21 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Corona, et al. [45] study 2 b |
-0.42 |
91 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
87 |
21 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Crouch, et al. [46] |
-0.53 |
128 |
GQ-6 |
HADS |
Cross |
69 |
50 |
USA |
MS patients |
Deichert, et al. [47] |
-0.42 |
181 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
66 |
21 |
USA |
Students |
Disabato, et al. [2] |
-0.33 |
797 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Long |
83 |
39 |
43 countries |
Adults |
Enko [48] |
-0.30 |
196 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
51 |
21 |
Poland |
Students |
Fenollar Bataller [49] |
-0.41 |
48 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
67 |
37 |
USA |
Religious congregation |
Froh, et al. [50] |
-0.43 |
1035 |
GQ-6: GRAT: GAC |
CES-D Children |
Cross |
49 |
16 |
USA |
High school students |
Gavian [51] dissertation |
-0.57 |
271 |
GQ-6 |
DASS-214 |
Cross |
70 |
|
USA |
Undergraduates |
Greene and McGovern [52] |
-0.37 |
350 |
GQ-6 |
PHQ-9 |
Cross |
89 |
40 |
21 countries |
Death of a parent prior to age 18 |
Harbaugh [53] dissertation |
-0.48 |
164 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Long |
70 |
20 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Hoffman [54] |
-0.69 |
38 |
GQ-6 |
RDSI |
Cross |
37 |
616 |
USA |
Head and neck cancer group |
Kaniuka, et al. [55] |
-0.41 |
913 |
GQ-6 |
BDI-II |
Cross |
72 |
20 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Kashdan and Breen [56] |
-0.35 |
144 |
GQ-6 |
BDI-II |
Cross |
78 |
24 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Kleiman, et al. [57] |
-0.36 |
369 |
GQ-6 |
BDI-II |
Cross |
85 |
22 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Koenog, et al. [58] |
-0.31 |
129 |
GQ-6 |
BDI-II |
Cross |
70 |
51 |
USA |
Religious adults |
Lambert, et al. [3] |
-0.29 |
746 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Long |
83 |
196 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Langer, et al. [59] |
-0.53 |
331 |
GQ-6 |
DASS-214 |
Cross |
70 |
38 |
Chile |
Adults |
Lau and Cheng [60] |
-0.17 -0.12 |
101 |
GQ-6: GAC |
CES-D |
Cross |
82 |
58 |
China |
Caregivers |
Lee, et al. [61] |
-0.45 |
464 |
GQ-67 |
HADS |
Cross |
0 |
|
South Korea |
Firefighters |
Li, et al. [62] |
-0.03 |
321 |
GQ-68 |
CES-D8 |
Cross |
0 |
China |
HIV infected men who have sex with other men |
|
Liang, et al. [63] |
-0.40 |
501 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
52 |
20 |
China |
Undergraduates |
Lin [9] |
-0.31 |
235 |
GQ-68 |
CES-D8 |
Cross |
62 |
20 |
Taiwan |
Students |
Lin [64] |
-0.34 |
814 |
IUG8 |
CES-D8 |
Cross |
68 |
20 |
Taiwan |
Undergraduates |
Lin [65] |
-0.47 |
287 |
IUG8 |
CES-D8 |
Cross |
77 |
20 |
Taiwan |
Undergraduates |
Liu, et al. [40] |
-0.31 |
445 |
GRAT |
SDS |
Cross |
75 |
24 |
China |
Undergraduates |
Mann [66] |
-0.30 |
333 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
67 |
25 |
43 Countries |
Modern orthodox single adults |
Martin, et al. [67] |
-0.14 |
108 |
GQ-6 |
HADS |
Long |
86 |
39 |
UK |
Parents of children with a disability |
McCullough, et al. [5] study 1 |
-0.30 |
238 |
GQ-6 |
BSI |
Cross |
73 |
21 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Mills, et al. [68] |
-0.46 |
186 |
GQ-6 |
BDI |
Cross |
5 |
66 |
|
Heart failure patients |
Olawa and Idemudia [69] |
-0.27 |
465 |
GQ-6 |
GDS |
Cross |
63 |
74 |
Nigeria |
Older adults |
Padilla-Walker, et al. [11] |
-0.18 |
500 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D children |
Long |
52 |
13 |
USA |
Adolescents |
Petrocchi and Couyoumdjian [70] |
-0.45 |
410 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
61 |
33 |
Italy |
Adults |
Renshaw and Rock [71] |
-0.40 |
97 |
GQ-6 |
DASS-214 |
Cross |
86 |
20 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Rey, et al. [12] |
-0.49 |
1617 |
GQ-65 |
CDI-S5 |
Cross |
50 |
14 |
Spain |
Adolescents |
Rey, et al. [72] |
-0.47 |
569 |
GQ-65 |
CDI-S5 |
Cross |
49 |
15 |
Spain |
Adolescents |
Ruini and Vescovelli [14] |
-0.36 |
67 |
GQ-6 |
SQ |
Cross |
100 |
57 |
Italy |
Breast cancer patients |
Sánchez-Álvarez, et al. [73] |
-0.48 |
1661 |
GQ-6 |
CDI-S5 |
Cross |
50 |
14 |
Spain |
Students |
Sánchez‐Álvarez, et al. [74] |
-0.27 |
2500 |
GQ-6 |
DASS-214 |
Long |
58 |
34 |
Spain |
Adolescents and adults |
Sánchez‐Álvarez, et al. [75] |
-0.42 |
1013 |
GQ-6 |
BDI-II |
Cross |
51 |
40 |
Spain |
Adults |
Sherman, et al. [76] |
-0.48 |
64 |
GQ-6 |
HADS |
Long |
43 |
28 |
USA |
Cystic fibrosis patients |
Simon [77] |
-0.45 |
477 |
GQ-6 |
MINI-MASQ |
Cross |
57 |
19 |
Philippines |
Undergraduates |
Sirois and Wood [15] arthritis |
-0.50 |
423 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
88 |
45 |
UK |
Arthritis patients |
Sirois and Wood [15] IBD |
-0.49 |
427 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
77 |
36 |
UK |
IBD patients |
Stoeckel, et al. [78] |
-0.36: -0.48 |
136 |
GQ-6: GRAT |
CES-D |
Cross
|
47 |
19 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Tam, et al. [13] |
-0.39 |
439 |
GQ-68 |
HADS6 |
Cross |
53 |
10 |
China |
Children |
Tehranchi, et al. [79] |
-0.16 |
200 |
VIA-IS-240 |
BDI-II |
Cross |
69 |
30 |
Iran |
Adults diagnosed with MDD |
Tulbure [80] |
-0.36 |
113 |
GQ-6 |
BDI-II |
Cross |
70 |
33 |
Romania |
Adults |
Van Dusen [81] thesis |
-0.45: -0.47 |
93
|
GQ-6: GRAT |
CES-D |
Cross |
80 |
19 |
USA |
Undergraduates |
Van Dusen [82] dissertation |
-0.35 |
268 |
GQ-6 |
PHQ-9 |
Cross |
66 |
47 |
USA |
Medical centre patients |
Van Dusen, et al. [83] |
-0.36 |
389 |
GQ-6 |
PHQ-9 |
Cross |
75 |
20 |
USA |
Undergraduates with trauma |
Watkins, et al. [16] study 2 population 1 |
-0.34 |
154 |
GRAT |
BDI-II |
Cross |
|
|
USA |
Undergraduates |
Watkins, et al. [16] study 2 population 2 |
-0.54 |
66 |
GRAT |
BDI-II |
Cross |
|
|
USA |
Undergraduates |
Watkins, et al. [16] study 2 population 3 |
-0.56 |
57 |
GRAT |
BDI-II |
Cross |
|
|
USA |
Undergraduates |
Wood, et al. [84] study 1 |
-0.24 |
156 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Long |
51 |
|
UK |
Undergraduates |
Wood, et al. [84] study 2 |
-0.48 |
87 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Long |
86 |
|
UK |
Undergraduates |
Wood, et al. [85] |
-0.31 |
201 |
GQ-6 |
NEO-PI-R |
Cross |
64 |
|
UK |
Undergraduates |
Wu, et al. [86] |
-0.38 |
358 |
GQ-68 |
TDS8 |
Cross |
63 |
19 |
China |
Undergraduates |
Yuan, et al. (Unpublished) |
-0.37 |
389 |
GRAT |
CES-D |
Cross |
64 |
21 |
China |
Undergraduates |
Zhang, et al. [87] |
-0.42 |
468 |
GQ-6 |
DASS-214 |
Cross |
58 |
19 |
China |
Undergraduates |
Zhang, et al. [88] |
-0.45 |
112 |
GQ-6 |
CES-D |
Cross |
42 |
21 |
China |
Adults with a disability |
GRAT: Gratitude Resentment and Appreciation Scale [16]; GQ-6: The Gratitude Questionnaire [5]; GAC: The Gratitude Adjective List [5]; IUG: Inventory of Undergraduates Gratitude [89]; VIA-IS-240: VIA Inventory of Strengths [90]; BDI-II: Beck Depression Inventory-II [23]; DASS-21: Depression Anxiety and Stress Scale [20]; CES-D: Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale [18]; CES-D Children: Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale for Children [91]; BSI: Brief Symptom Inventory [92]; PHQ-9: Patient Health Questionnaire (Spritzer, et al.); HADS: Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale [24]; RDSI: Reynolds Depression Screening Inventory [93]; MINI-MASQ: Mini Mood and Anxiety Symptom Questionnaire [94)]; SDS: Self-rating Depression Scale [95]; GDS: Geriatric Depression Scale [96]; CDI-S: Children's Depression Inventory Short Version [97]; SQ: Symptom Questionnaire [98]; NEO-PI-R: Revised neo personality inventory (Costa & McRae); TDS: Trait Depression Subscale of the State-Trait Depression Questionnaire [99].