Table 1: Overview of study design, results and contributions.

 

 

Study I

Study II

Study III

Study IV

Design

Cross-sectional, digital platform

Two-wave RCT (face to face) intervention

Cross-sectional, digital platform

Three-wave RCT (digital) intervention

Theoretical foundation

SDT

SDT, MI, RPM CBT

SDT

SDT, RPM, TTM

Participants

1091 adult men (n = 286) and women (n = 805), aged 18-78 years (M = 45.0; SD = 11.7), all were active members of a web based Swedish exercise program.

64 Swedish undergraduate university students (women n = 49 and men n = 15) aged 19-49 years (M = 27.3; SD = 7.4).

Sample A: N = 1084, web-based exercise service members, mean age 45 (SD = 11.7). Sample B: N = 511 university students with a mean age of 22 years (SD = 3.3).

318 adult women (n = 279) and men (n = 40) aged 23-67 years (M = 46.7; SD = 9.4) participating in a digital step contest provided by their employer.

Measures

BPNES, BREQ-2, LTEQ

PNES, BREQ-2, LTEQ

BPNES, BREQ-2, LTEQ

BPNES, BREQ-2, LTEQ

Analyses 

SEM, MVA

ANCOVA, MVA

LPA

ANCOVA, MVA

Results

Self-determined exercise motivation (identified regulation) mediated the relationship between basic psychological need satisfaction and exercise in the full sample. Moderationsof gender and age werealsofound.

Post-intervention effects showed increased levels of total and strenuous exercise, and this effect was mediated by self-determined motivation (identified regulation).

Six profiles were found in both samples. Some profiles were found in both samples whereas others were unique to each sample. More self-determined profiles demonstrated higher scores on need satisfaction and exercise.

The intervention increased levels of total, strenuous and light exercise and predicted mediators in terms of motivational quality. Moderations of gender and age were also found.

Limitations

Cross-sectional design, sample constitution (mainly women, high mean age) and self-reported exercise.

Small sample of convenience, self-reported exercise, exclusion of the relatedness need dimension and only having two measure points.

Cross-sectional design, sample constitution (mainly women, high mean age) and self-reported exercise.

High drop-out, sample constitution (mainly women, high mean age), self-reported exercise.

Contributions

Validation of Swedish translations of BPNES and BREQ-2

 

Employing a large sample of middle-aged adults in an e-health context

 

Using SEM and advanced and modern recommended MVA

 

Generating a full mediation model of steps 3-5 in the SDT process model along with moderating effects of gender and age, hence not only examining general relationships between variables but also when, for whom, and why they are associated.

Short-term exercise intervention

 

Applying polytheoretical intervention tailoring

 

Operating in a real-world setting

 

Using advanced and modern recommended MVA

Support for the motivational soup, i.e., that motivation is a multidimensional construct and that people have different, sometimes competing, reasons for engaging in exercise.

 

Using person-oriented analyses to examine within-person interactions of motivation and different regulations.

Short term exercise intervention in a digital context.

 

Amotivation was involved in statistically significant main (time) effects, as well as in mediating the intervention effects. The intervention decreased controlled motivation (external regulation) and amotivation.

 

Results of moderation analyses suggest that the stipulated mechanisms between exercise, motivation and psychological need satisfaction in this study hold for women, but not for men, and for older, but not for younger adults.