Table 1: Characteristics of the studies
included
Author, |
Group |
WBV setting |
Co-intervention |
Outcomes |
Drop-out rate |
Adverse effects |
|
year |
Device,Freq,Dis |
Exercises |
|||||
Berschin, 2014 |
WBV 27 ± 4.2 y;
FM) |
Galileo, 5-9 mm |
1st-5th wk:body weight exercises (1.5-2 min × 5 sets/exercise) |
Physical
therapy 5 d/wk × 10 wk |
ISOM, ISOK,postural stability test,knee
laxity,LSS |
0/20 |
Pain or
swelling after exercise (60% of participants) |
3.8 d/wk × 10 wk, 40 ± 2.3
min/session |
|||||||
CON 28 ± 6.8 y;
FM) |
NA |
Resistance
exercise and balance training3-4 d/wk× 10 wk,85 ±
4.4 min/session |
0/20 |
Pain or
swelling after exercise (70% of participants) |
|||
Fu, 2013 |
WBV |
Fitvibe, 4 mm |
11 body
weight exercises (30-45 s/set × 1-3 sets/exercise) 2d/wk × 8 wk |
WBVT and
CON |
Position sense,knee laxity,postural stability,ISOK, range of motion,single-leg
hop test,triple-hop test, shuttle run,carioca test |
5/24 |
No |
CON |
NA |
4/24 |
|||||
Moezy, |
WBV |
Power
Plate, |
9
exercises(30-60 s/set × 1-3 sets/exercise) 3 d/wk × 4 wk |
NA |
Position sense,postural stability |
2/12 |
No |
2008 |
30-50Hz, 2.5-5.0 mm |
||||||
CON |
NA |
Resistance
exercise (3sets/exercise × 8-10 exercises, 10 RM), flexibility,
proprioception training |
1/11 |
Abbreviations:
CON, conventional rehabilitation program; Dis, displacement; F, female; FM,
female and male; Freq, frequency; ISOK, isokinetic
muscle strength; ISOM, isometric contraction; LSS, Lysholm
scoring scale; NA, not applicable; NR, not reported; RM, repetition maximum;
WBV, whole-body vibration.
Devices: Fitvibe Excel Pro (model 332015; GymnaUniphy
NV, Bilzen, Belgium); Galileo 2000 WBV machine (Novotec Medical GmbH,Pforzheim,
Germany); Power Plate (Power Plate International, Northbrook, IL, USA).