Table 1: Prevalence of affective disorders before surgery.

 

Author and Publication year

Country

Study features

N Participants

Mean age

Sex

Other features of the study

Surgery/Setting

Instruments

Results

Da Silva et al. 2015 [34]

Marseille (France)

Retrospective study

92

/

/

Focusing on lifetime mood disorders prevalence

Candidates to surgery

Standardized evaluation of psychiatric comorbidity

Lifetime mood disorders prevalence: 33 % bipolar disorder, 29 % depressive disorder.  48 % of patients suffering from bipolar disorder were previously diagnosed as suffering from major depressive disorder. 60 % of the patients suffering from major depressive disorder were not considered to have any mood disorder.

Grothe KB et al. 2014 [31]

Rochester (MN-USA)

Retrospective study

935

47.4 ± 12.3 years

75% F

Bipolar disorder prevalence

Candidates to surgery

Mood Disorder Questionnaire (MDQ); BDI-II

5.8% of the preoperative sample screened positive for symptoms of BD, 22% of BD patients underwent bariatric surgery.

Duarte-Guerra LS et al. 2014 [32]

Sao Paulo, Brazil

Retrospective study

393

43

79.1% F

To replicate previous findings on frequency of psychiatric disorders and associated factors among obese patients seeking bariatric surgery

Candidates to surgery

SCID-I

Current anxiety disorders 46.3%; lifetime psychiatric disorders 80.9%; lifetime affective disorders 64.9%, bipolar disorders 35.6%, depressive disorders 29.3%.

Salwen JK et al. 2014 [30]

New York

Retrospective study

187

 

 

Childhood abuse and adult interpersonal abuse prevalence

Candidates to surgery

 

61% childhood abuse, 30.5% adult interpersonal abuse, 15% depressive symptoms.

Hayden MJ et al. 2014 [36]

Australia

Prospective observational study

204

 

 

To evaluate the comorbidity Axis I; follow up study (2 years),

LAGB

 

39.7% Axis I, Mood disorders 26.5%, Anxiety disorders 15.2%, BED 13.2%. After surgery: Axis I 20%.

Lin HY et al. 2013 [37]

Taiwan

Retrospective study

841

 

M/F

Patients 2007-2010

Bariatric surgery vs Non-surgical

Taiwanese Depression Questionnaire (TDQ); Chinese Health Questionnaire (CHQ), SCID

42% mental disorders, mood disorders 27% in surgical group.

Mitchell et al. 2012 [103]

Pittsburgh (USA)

Retrospective study

199

46

M/F

Current and lifetime Axis I disorders

LAGB, RYGB

Longitudinal Assessment of bariatric Surgery

MDD lifetime 38.7%, MDD current 7%.

Hayden MJ et al., 2012 [33]

Melbourne (Australia)

Observational study

201

 

 

Evaluate BDI validity in obese patients

Candidates to surgery

SCID-I, BDI-I, BDI IA

26.9% (54) Mood Disorders, 37 MDD.

Alciati  A. et al. 2011 [105]

Milan (Italy)

Retrospective study

120

44.4 ± 10.7 (bipolar spectrum); 41.6 ± 10.9 (no psychiatric disorders)

17m/55 F (bipolar spectrum

To evaluate the rate of childhood parental loss and relation with bipolar spectrum

Candidates to surgery

SCID-CV semi-structured interview related to childhood parental loss

91.7% had a bipolar spectrum disorder; 28% reported a childhood parental loss, more frequent in BD II.

Abiles V et al. 2010 [106]

Granada (Spain)

Observational study

50 patients (26 type III Obesity, 24 type IV Obesity) and 25 normal-weight controls

O-IV 38.54; O-III 39.31; CN 40.72

M/F

To analyze the psychopathological characteristics of obese candidates for bariatric surgery

Candidates to surgery

General Health Questionnaire, Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale, Apgar Family Function Questionnaire, Spanish version of the Quality of Life Index, Eysenck Personality Questionnaire-Revised, Food Craving Questionnaire-Trait, Eating Disorders Examination-Questionnaire Version-4

The depression score significantly differed among groups, with the O-III and O-IV groups showing the highest values.

Muhlhans et al. 2009 [17]

Erlangen (Germany)

Observational study

145

38.6 for F; 39.1 for M

M/F (146)

To investigate the prevalence of Axis I psychopathology in bariatric surgery candidates

Candidates to surgery

Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV (SCID); Eating Disorder Examination (EDE)

Lifetime MDD 50.7%, current MDD 25.3%.

Mauri et al. 2008 [16]

Pisa (Italy)

Observational study

282

 

M/F

Prevalence Axis I-II and QoL

Candidates to surgery

SCID I-II, Ham-D Bulimic Investigatory Test, short-form Quality of Life Enjoyment and Satisfaction Questionnaire

Lifetime Axis I 37.6%; Mood Disorders lifetime 22.0%, current MDD 4.5%. QoL significantly more impaired in patients with comorbid Axis I.

Wildes JE et al. 2008 [107]

Pittsburgh (USA)

Retrospective study

230

 

 

Childhood maltreatment and Axis I diagnosis

Candidates to surgery

Childhood Trauma Questionnaire, short form;

SCID-I

66% history of childhood maltreatment; elevated rates of both unipolar and bipolar mood disorders.

Kalarchian et al. 2007 [15]

 

Observational study

288

 

 

Prevalence psychiatric disorders

Candidates to surgery

 

Lifetime psychiatric disorders (66.3%); Bipolar Disorder 1.4%.

Alciati et al. 2007 [12]

Milan

(Italy)

Retrospective study

83

44.4 ± 10.7

M/F

To investigate the prevalence of bipolar spectrum (including sybsyndromal hypomania) in patients seeking surgical treatment).

Candidates to surgery

SCID-CV questionnaire; Hypomania Symptom Check list (HCL-32)

Bipolar spectrum disorder 89% of the sample, highest prevalence BD -II, comorbidity with panic disorder 30%.

Rosenburger PH et al. 2006 [14]

New Haven (USA)

Retrospective study

174

 

 

Current and lifetime psychiatric disorders and association with eating disorders

Candidates to surgery

SCID-I

MDD 14.9% (Lifetime), 3.4% (Current).

Sanchez-Romàn S. et al.  2003 [27]

Mexico

Retrospective study

70

49 +/-10.4

25 M, 35 F

 

Candidates to surgery

SCID-I

60% Axis I disorder, most frequent anxiety disorders and mood disorders.

 

 

 

F: Female; M: Male; RYGB: Roux-Y-Gastric Bypass; LAGB: Laparoscopic Adjustable Gastric Banding; MDD: Major Depressive Disorder; BD: Bipolar Disorder; BED: Binge Eating Disorder; SCID-I: Structured Clinical Interview for DSM IV Axis I disorders; Ham-D: Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression; BDI: Beck Depression Inventory; Beck Depression Inventory-II (BDI-II); QoL: Quality of Life