Table 9: Between groups comparisons - times of onset and duration of OMERACT-OARSI responses, in the treatment groups in relation to the radiographic grade and patterns, and number of therapeutic courses.
|
|
Absolute Differences/(Relative -Percentage Differences) |
||||||||
Group |
|
Indicator |
M1 |
M2 |
M3 |
M5 |
M6 |
M18 |
M24 |
M30 |
NS |
K/L-II ‘H’† |
PW-VAS |
8 (20%) |
6 (15%) |
4 (10%) |
0 (0%) |
10 (24%)# |
-4 (-10%) |
-7 (-17%) |
-9 (-22%) |
WOMAC-C |
9 (28%) |
7 (22%) |
5 (16%) |
1 (3%) |
10 (31%)# |
-3 (-9%) |
-6 (-19%) |
-8 (-25%) |
||
K/L-II ‘I’† |
PW-VAS |
8 (19%) |
6 (14%) |
4 (9%) |
0 (0%) |
8 (19%) |
-5(-12%) |
-8 (-19%) |
-11 (-26%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
(24%) |
(18%) |
(12%) |
(0%) |
(24%) |
-(-18%) |
-(-24%) |
-1 (-33%) |
||
K/L-II ‘A’† |
PW-VAS |
7 (16%) |
5 (11%) |
3(7%) |
-1 (-2%) |
7 (16%) |
-7 (-16%) |
-10 (-22%) |
-13 (-29%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
8 (22%) |
6 (17) |
4 (11%) |
0 (0%) |
7 (19%) |
-6 (-17%) |
-9 (-25%) |
-12 (-33%) |
||
K/L-III ‘H’† |
PW-VAS |
8 (17%) |
7 (15%) |
5 (10%) |
2 (4%) |
10 (21%) |
-3 (-6%) |
-6 (-13%) |
-10 (-21%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
7 (18%) |
6 (16%) |
4 (11%) |
1 (3%) |
9 (24%) |
-4 (-11%) |
-7 (-18%) |
-11 (-29%) |
||
K/L-III ‘I’† |
PW-VAS |
7 (14%) |
6 (12%) |
4 (8%) |
1 (2%) |
8 (16%) |
-4 (-8%) |
-8 (-16%) |
-12 (-24%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
8 (20%) |
7 (17%) |
5 (12%) |
2 (5%) |
9 (22%) |
-4 (-10%) |
-8 (-20%) |
-11 (-27%) |
||
K/L-III ‘A’† |
PW-VAS |
7 (13%) |
5 (10%) |
3 (6%) |
0 (0%) |
7 (13%) |
-9 (-17%) |
-14 (-27%) |
-20 (-39%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
7 (16%) |
5 (12%) |
4 (9%) |
0 (0%) |
7 (16%) |
-8 (-19%) |
-14 (-33%) |
-19 (-44%) |
||
DM |
K/L-II ‘H’† |
PW-VAS |
15 (37%)* |
15 (37%)* |
14 (34%)* |
12 (29%)* |
28 (68%)# |
17 (42%)# |
13 (32%)# |
8 (20%) |
WOMAC-C |
16 (50%)* |
15 (47%)* |
15 (47%)* |
13 (41%)* |
28 (88%)# |
18 (56%)# |
16 (50%)# |
9 (28%) |
||
K/L-II ‘I’† |
PW-VAS |
13 (30%) |
13 (30%) |
12 (28%) |
11 (26%) |
24 (56%)# |
14 (33%)# |
9 (21%) |
4 (9%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
14 (41%) |
14 (41%) |
13 (38%) |
11 (32%) |
25 (74%)# |
14 (41%)# |
9 (27%) |
4 (12%) |
||
K/L-III ‘H’† |
PW-VAS |
10 (21%) |
10 (21%) |
9 (19%) |
8 (17%) |
18 (38%)# |
7 (15%) |
4 (8%) |
-2 (-4%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
10 (26%) |
10 (26%) |
9 (24%) |
8 (21%) |
18 (47%)# |
7 (18%) |
2 (5%) |
-3 (-8%) |
||
K/L-III ‘I’† |
PW-VAS |
9 (18%) |
9 (18%) |
8 (16%) |
6 (12%) |
15 (30%)# |
4 (8%) |
-1 (-2%) |
-7 (-14%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
10 (24%) |
9 (22%) |
9 (22%) |
7 (17%) |
16 (39%)# |
5 (12%) |
-1 (-2%) |
-6 (-15%) |
||
MMW-HA |
K/L-II ‘H’† |
PW-VAS |
10 (24%) |
13 (32%)* |
15 (37%)* |
14 (34%)* |
23 (56%)# |
23 (56%)# |
19 (46%)# |
14 (34%)# |
WOMAC-C |
9 (29%) |
13 (42%)* |
14 (45%)* |
14 (45%)* |
23 (74%)# |
23 (74%)# |
19 (61%)# |
14 (45%)# |
||
K/L-II ‘I’† |
PW-VAS |
9 (21%) |
12 (28%)* |
13 (30%)* |
13 (30%)* |
22 (51%)# |
20 (47%)# |
16 (37%)# |
11 (26%)# |
|
WOMAC-C |
10 (29%) |
13 (38%)* |
14 (41%)* |
12 (35%)* |
22 (65%)# |
21 (62%)# |
17 (50%)# |
12 (35%)# |
||
K/L-II ‘A’† |
PW-VAS |
8 (18%) |
11 (24%)* |
12 (27%)* |
11 (24%)* |
19 (42%)# |
15 (33%)# |
10 (22%)# |
5 (11%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
8 (22%) |
12 (33%)* |
13 (36%)* |
11 (31%)* |
20 (56%)# |
15 (42%)# |
11 (31%)# |
6 (17%) |
||
K/L-III ‘H’† |
PW-VAS |
8 (17%) |
11 (24%)* |
12 (25%)* |
12 (25%)* |
20 (42%)# |
17 (35%)# |
12 (25%)# |
8 (17%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
8 (21%) |
11 (31%)* |
12 (32%)* |
11 (29%)* |
20 (53%)# |
17 (45%)# |
12 (32%)# |
8 (21%) |
||
K/L-III ‘I’† |
PW-VAS |
8 (16%) |
10 (20%)* |
11 (22%)* |
10 (20%)* |
18 (36%)# |
13 (26%)# |
8 (16%) |
2 (4%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
8 (20%) |
11 (27%)* |
12 (29%)* |
11 (27%)* |
19 (46%)# |
14 (34%)# |
8 (20%) |
3 (7%) |
||
K/L-III ‘A’† |
PW-VAS |
8 (15%) |
10 (19%) |
11 (21%)* |
9 (17%) |
17 (32%)# |
8 (15%) |
0 (0.0%) |
-8 (-15%) |
|
WOMAC-C |
8 (19%) |
10 (23%) |
10 (23%)* |
9 (21%) |
17 (40%)# |
7 (16%) |
0 (0.0%) |
-8 (-19%) |
*- OARSI-responses after first course; #- OARSI-responses after second course; †-Each study group included 25 subjects; K/L - radiographic grade according to Kellgren-Lawrence; ‘A’ /’I’ /’H’ - atrophic/normotrophic/hypertrophic patterns; PW-VAS - pan at walking by VAS; WOMAC-C - WOMAC function scale.