Table 4: Summary of studies investigating post-adenotonsillectomy morbidity rates for paediatric patients.
Authors | Study design | Patients | Incidence (No. [%]) of morbidity | Time of morbidity | Definition of morbidity/respiratory adverse event (AE) |
Theilhaber, et al. [8] | Retrospective | OSA patients admitted to ICU post-adenotonsillectomy | 26/72 [36.1] | Median time = 165 minutes | • Mild AE : Saturation < 95% requiring supplementary O2 or repositioning • Severe AE : desaturation treated by bag & mask ventilation, CPAP, BiPAP, oropharyngeal airway or re-intubation, and unplanned ICU admission |
Kieran, et al. [13] | Retrospective | OSA and Non-OSA patients | 294/4092 [7.2] | - | • Saturations < 90% |
Statham, et al. [14] | Retrospective | OSA patients | 149/2315 [6.4] | - | • SpO2 < 90% requiring O2 supplementation or diuretic therapy • Apnoea/increased work of breathing requiring nasopharygeal airway support/CPAP/intubation & mechanical ventilation • Chest radiographic evidence of atelectasis, infiltrates, edema, pneumomediastinum, pneumothorax, or pleural effusion |
Kalra, et al. [15] | Retrospective | OSA patients | 198/3739 [5.3] | - | • SpO2 < 90% requiring O2 supplementation for > 8 hrs or diuretics • Apnoea/increased work of breathing requiring nasopharygeal airway support/CPAP/intubation & mechanical ventilation • Chest radiographic evidence of atelectasis, infiltrates, edema & air fluid collection in pleural cavity |
Brown, et al. [10] | Retrospective | OSA patients a) Urgent adenotonsillectomy* b) Elective adenotonsillectomy |
a) 33/54 [61] b) 16/44 [36] |
a) Minor intervention group [22/33]: • 36.4% < 1 hr post-op Major intervention group [11/33]: • 72.7% < 1 hr post-op b) Not documented |
• Saturation < 95% or • Airway obstruction or • Requiring intervention |
Wilson, et al. [16] | Retrospective | OSA patients | 34/163 [21] | - | • Saturation < 95% or • Airway obstruction or • Requiring medical interventions eg. O2 administration, jaw thrust, artificial airway, positive pressure ventilation, reintubation |
Biavati, et al. [17] | Retrospective | Patients with obstructed breathing during sleep | 8/355 [2.25] | - | • Upper airway obstruction, oxygen desaturations less than 90% and interventions (eg placement of a nasopharyngeal airway, endotracheal intubation, or administration of supplementary oxygen) • A planned post-operative admission with interventions • An unplanned post-operative admission • Readmission after discharge for airway complications, or any airway complication that was managed on an outpatient basis |
Gerber, et al. [18] | Prospective | OSA and non-OSA patients | 44/29 [15.1] | - | At least 1 of the following occurring ≥ 2 hrs after surgery: • O2 saturation level < 90% for ≥ 10 sec • An obstructive breathing pattern • Respiratory distress requiring intervention |
Rosen, et al. [19] | Retrospective | OSA patients | 10/37 [27] | 'within hours of surgery' | • Saturations < 80% or • Snoring, increased respiratory effort, or • Requiring intervention eg. repositioning, supplemental oxygen, CPAP/BiPAP, prolonged intubation or reintubation |
McColley, et al. [20] | Retrospective | OSA patients | 16/69 [23] | 'Up to 14 hours after completion of the operative procedure' | • Saturations ≤ 70% and/or • Hypercapnia (PaCO > 45 mmHg) • Requiring nurse/physician intervention |
Wiatrak, et al. [21] | Retrospective | OSA and non-OSA patients | 14/20 [70] | - | • O2 desaturation > 90% requiring any combination of supplemental oxygen, placement of a nasopharyngeal airway, or endotracheal intubation • Postoperative obstruction apnoea, manifested by a cessation of airflow in the presence of respiratory muscle activity for > 10 s • Post-operative central apnoea, manifested by a cessation of airflow for periods > 10s with no observable respiratory muscle activity |
*: Urgent adenotonsillectomy is defined by Brown, et al. as adenotonsillectomy being performed during same hospital admission following diagnosis of OSA in a sleep study.