Acute infection with the novel coronavirus causing COVID-19 illness results in a wide range of clinical manifestations in the general adult population. The clinical course and effects in non-athletic people have already been studied, but insufficient data is available on athletics.
This study is designed to evaluate the pattern, clinical course, the outcome of COVID-19 among athletics in Basrah city in the south of Iraq.
A comparative study design was used to compare 18 athletics with sexed and aged match 22 non-athletic.
The study found that no noticeable difference between the duration of hospitalization between the two groups and all the inflammatory biomarkers was slightly lower among the athletics. In addition, the severity of disease among the athletes was less as the higher degree of lung involvement, the severe desaturation, and the occurrence of cytokine storm were higher among non-athletic; moreover, the response to antiviral drug "remdesivir" and the recovery outcome were higher among athletics.
Athletics, Basrah, COVID-19, Iraq
The Corona virus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic was triggered by a modified coronavirus leading to severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), which quickly spread from China to all continents [1]. The disease has spread worldwide, resulting in a pandemic that is still ongoing [2]. COVID-19's clinical course and effects in non-athletic populations have already been studied, and they are primarily dependent on the existence of comorbidities and age [3]. Although the infection may be asymptomatic; the clinical course is usually mild to moderate in the majority of patients [4].
Moreover, COVID-19 clinical symptoms, consequences, and response to treatment in physically active people, particularly professional athletes, are little understood [5]. Furthermore, the most common reason for hospitalization is pulmonary involvement with inflammatory pneumonitis; however, other clinical presentations such as cytokine storm and other systemic complications may be the reason an individual develops a protracted illness course and delays recovery [6]. Although it was suggested that a high degree of physical fitness might protect against the likelihood of severe disease that necessitates hospitalization, it is unclear if this influences the course and recovery patterns in COVID-19 [7].
This study aims to evaluate the pattern of COVID-19 among athletics concerning the respiratory severity, the development of cytokine storms, and the outcome.
A case-control study was carried for three months period from the 1st of July to the 1st of October 2021 on hospitalized athletics in Basrah teaching hospital, a specialized center dealing with COVID-19 in Basrah city in the south of Iraq. During this period, 18 athletics were detected. Their information and clinical characteristics were taken from the medical records. They plotted on an organized questionnaire which included the following variables: Patient's factors (age, sex, and comorbidities), disease severity (the oxygen saturation, the degree of lung involvement, and the development of cytokine storm through clinical and biochemical assessment which includes increasing tachypnoea and oxygen requirement with elevated interlukin-6 levels and serum ferritin) [8], The duration of hospitalization, The levels of inflammatory markers (serum ferritin, interleukin-6, D. dimer, lactate dehydrogenase, and C-reactive protein), the response to the antiviral drug "remdesivir" and the outcome (recovery, death and pulmonary fibrosis). Athletics parameters were assessed in comparisons with parameters of 22 non-athletics patients, both groups were matched for age and sex. Non-athletics patients were collected from the same site in Basrah teaching hospital.
Verbal and written informed consent from the patients who enrolled in the study was taken, and approval from the Basrah medical college ethical committee and from the development and training center of the Basra health directorate/ministry of health was also waved.
For the statistical analysis, the Computerized SPSS version 20 program is used to analyse the study results. Quantitative data are tabulated as mean ± standard deviation (SD); t-test will be used for two groups comparison. Qualitative data are tabulated as numbers (%) and tested with the Pearson Chi-square test. P-value <0.05 is considered statistically significant.
Eighteen athletics patients were included in this study, all of them were males, and their mean age was 38.78 years, and their characteristics concerning the age, sex, medical illnesses, in addition to the duration and site of admission was summarized in the Table 1.
Table 1: Demographic and non-demographic characteristics of the athletics patients. View Table 1
Furthermore, the degree of lung involvement was assessed by chest CT scan and classified into less or more than 50% of the lung damage. Additionally, the oxygen saturation and the presence or absence of cytokine storm depending on clinical and laboratory criteria were also taken into consideration. Moreover, the information related to the response to antiviral drug "remdesivir" and the clinical outcome was assessed in this study. Additionally, the exact level of the inflammatory biomarkers was registered, and all these parameters were summarized in Table 2.
Table 2: The clinical and laboratory features of the athletics patients involved in the study. View Table 2
The results in Table 3 show that there was no significant difference (p-value < 0.05) in duration of hospitalization between the two groups and all the inflammatory biomarkers, except C-reactive protein, were non-significantly (p-value < 0.05) higher among the non-athletics. The level of C-reactive protein is significantly less (p-value = 0.021) in athletics patients compared with non-athletics patients.
Table 3: The comparison of Age, duration of admission and the levels of inflammatory biomarkers between athletics, and non-athletics patients. View Table 3
The degree of lung involvement was significantly higher among non-athletes (p-value = 0.046). Although the rate of ICU (intensive care unit) admission in athletes being less than that in non-athletes, but this was of no statistical significance (p-value = 0.73). Additionally, the severity of disease according to SpO2 was insignificantly less in athletes compared with non-athletics (p-value = 0.673). Moreover, cytokine storm was insignificantly more in non-athletic (p-value = 0.169). Furthermore, the patient's response to the antiviral drug "remdesivir" was insignificantly better and with a higher percentage of an earlier response (p-value = 0.258). In addition to the outcome of the patients which show complete recovery in around 95% of athletics and no one of them diagnosed with signs of pulmonary fibrosis, in contrast to the non-athletics group in whom about 15% develop lung fibrosis but generally these findings of no statistical significance p-value = 0.158). These findings were summarized in Table 4.
Table 4: The comparison of the clinical parameters between athletics and non-athletics. View Table 4
To our knowledge, this is the first study in Basrah city and possibly in Iraq that highlights the group of athletes concerning COVID-19. The idea of this research was originated during the first pandemic wave as we noticed a few cases of athletes that showed severe and poor outcomes during the illness. Still, this bad outcome may reflect the underdevelopment of the treatment modality and lack of experience during that time, in addition to the co-existing co-morbidities among those candidates and their older age that may directly be related to the poor prognosis and worse outcome.
There is a scarcity of information about COVID-19 in athletes, and we cannot find a detailed survey among hospitalized athletics. One of the published studies held by Rajpal, et al. in 2021 found that 12 (46%) of 26 competitive collegiate athletes with COVID-19 had minor symptoms, whereas 54 percent were asymptomatic [9] additionally, Schumacher, et al. found a comparable number of asymptomatic athletes (58%) in their study [10]. Also, Krzywaski, et al. conducted a survey with 111 elite Polish athletes. In 16 percent of participants, asymptomatic illnesses were discovered. The vast majority of symptoms were minor, which appears to be consistent with overall projections for the same age range [11]. Additionally, COVID-19 was linked to a minor, self-limiting illness that lasted on average ten days in a cohort of 147 elite athletes in 2021. Still, it also caused a protracted impact on full sports participation in a fourth of the athletes, lasting more than a month [12].
From the pathological points of view, heterogeneous immune responses associated with childhood immunizations, frequent exposure to seasonal coronaviruses, and a more diversified memory T cell repertoire can explain the moderate clinical outcome of COVID-19 in younger athletes [13]. Furthermore, enhanced angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 expression is implicated in anti-inflammatory signaling and may lessen the risk of severe disease in young people [14].
To sum up the finding of our study, we can state that COVID-19-related illnesses in athletics had a comparable pattern and duration to those reported in the general population.
One of the significant limitations of this study is the small sample size of athletics which is more likely attributed to the lack of complete medical records details that make the author ignore any case with incomplete data. Additionally, the absence of serum troponin level and electrocardiography in those patients, which could be necessary for diagnosing cardiovascular complications, especially myocarditis in athletics patients.
We recommend a further study with larger sample size and longitudinal pattern to follow the effect on the health and the quality of life and the ability of the athletics in the future to return to their daily activity and exercise. Moreover, we also recommend studying cardiovascular complications such as myocarditis, which is suggested to increase among athletics with COVID-19.
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.
On a budget of researchers - self-funded research.
We want to acknowledge all resident doctors at Basrah teaching hospital for their efforts in providing us with the complete set of data, particularly Dr. Yasir Alaa Sabeeh, for his cooperation and work.